Stump Grinding vs. Stump Removal

Though tree stumps might not seem like a big issue it can be dangerous in many ways. They are not only hazardous for the health of your yard but also for your family. Tree stumps can be a major tripping hazard for children, pets, and old people and can cause serious injury. They can also prevent your garden from getting proper maintenance because they need to be worked around by mowers and other tools.

First of all, one thing everyone should keep in mind that stump grinding should not be done by homeowners or gardeners. If you attempt to grind or remove a stump on your own, you can end up damaging your tools, your property, and yourself. Both of these methods of tree felling should strictly be done with the help of professionals and their machinery.

What is stump grinding?

A tree grinder is a piece of heavy machinery that should be operated by a trained professional to remove the entire tree stump. The machine is powered by a petrol engine and consists of a hydraulically controlled arm and a cutting wheel. The wheel spins at a very high speed that cuts through and grinds the tree stump.

Stump grinding is one of the most effective forms of stump removal. It ensures the elimination of ants, bees, snakes, and any other pests.

Advantages of a stump grinder:

  • It is a very quick and effective method
  • It is less intrusive than stump removal
  • It is also considered eco-friendly and you can also use the leftover wood as you like it
  • This method leaves you with a flat area
  • Tree stump removal cost is also pocket-friendly

Disadvantages of stump removal:

  • Tree roots remain
  • This is potentially much messier than another method unless done by a good professional

What is stump removal?

This method is sometimes called stump-pulling. It requires the removal of the entire stump, including the roots. This is intrusive and requires a lot of force and machinery and hence, calling for professional help is necessary. While stump removal eliminates the stump entirely, it also creates a big hole in your yard.

Advantages of stump removal:

  • Eliminates the stump from the roots
  • Prevents regrowth of tree

Disadvantages of stump removal:

  • Typically costlier than stump grinding as this requires a lot of work
  • Is more intrusive than stump grinding
  • Leaves a huge hole in the yard which looks very unattractive and needs to be filled
  • This not so eco-friendly as the stump must be disposed of and often cannot be reused

Stump Grinding vs. Stump Removal: Which method is better

Though most stump removal companies offer both methods, some homeowners like to choose stump decay and decompose naturally, but this method takes time and encourage pests. The best method often depends on your requirements and purpose. If you want your tree removal cost to be low, you should look into the stump grinding option. If you want a method that removes the entire tree from the roots, you should go for the stump-pulling option.